To err is human but not in medical practice: The Famous Dr Hawa Garba Case

by The Welthi Bureau | 15 FEB 2018

to err is human but not in medical practice the famous dr hawa garba case
 Image used for representational purpose only

Dr KK Aggarwal explains how a  single clinical error can do away with all the good that they do as doctors.



The case of Dr Hadiza Hawa-Garba, a trainee pediatrician in the NHS-UK, convicted for homicide for the death of a child from sepsis, and hounded by the General Medical Council (GMC), is every junior doctors fear today.



Case synopsis



Jack, a 6-year-old boy with Down syndrome was referred by a GP for nausea, vomiting, and diarrhea on February 18, 2011. At 10:30 am Jack was assessed by Dr Hawa-Garba, a trainee pediatrician in the NHS-UK, who made a presumptive diagnosis of fluid depletion from gastroenteritis and gave IV fluid bolus and started maintenance fluids. The patient had a past history of repaired atrioventricular canal defect and was on enalapril.



The doctors ordered a chest x-ray, which was done at 12.30 pm. Blood count, renal function, and inflammatory markers were also done. Blood gases showed that Jack was acidotic with a pH of 7 and a lactate of 11. The metabolic profile confirmed her working diagnosis of shock from gastroenteritis; but, judging from the tests she ordered, pneumonia was in her differential. Repeat blood gas showed pH of 7.24, heading towards a normal pH of 7.4.



Dr Hawa-Garba looked at the chest x-ray only at 3 pm, which showed pneumonia. She prescribed antibiotics, which were given at 4 pm. At 4:30 pm, she met Dr ORiordan, her boss, in the hospital corridor. She showed him Jacks blood gas results and explained her plan of action. Her boss did not see Jack.



In the ward, Jack received enalapril. Dr Hawa-Garba had not prescribed enalapril, and she clearly stated in her treatment plan that enalapril must be stopped. Nor was enalapril given by the nursing staff. But, she did not make it clear to the mother not to give it, who subsequently gave it to the child that day at 7pm (Wikipedia). He suffered a cardiac arrest one hour after receiving enalapril. CPR was interrupted because Dr Hawa-Garba mistakenly believed that there was a DNR order for Jack, but was then continued with. Jack died from streptococcal sepsis at 9.20pm.




The verdict




Dr Hawa-Garba, and the two nurses who were caring for Jack, were charged with manslaughter. The doctor was not only clueless, but also grossly negligent.




Clinical errors or mistakes by the doctor cited were delay in getting chest x-ray, delay in reading the x-ray, which would have helped reaching a diagnosis of sepsis much earlier and delay in prescribing the antibiotics for the same.




Unwittingly, the court was exposing system failures, but Dr Hawa-Garba was being held responsible for each failed component. Expert doctors opined that had Jack received antibiotics within 30 minutes, rather than 6 hours, his chances of survival would have increased dramatically.




Dr Hawa-Garba was found guilty of manslaughter by gross negligence for the preventable death from sepsis; the jury returned the verdict 10:2 and was sentenced to two years in prison, suspended for two years. General Medical Council (GMC) appealed against that decision and called for Hawa-Garba’s “erasure from the medical register”.




The case made by the GMC was allowed in the High Court of Justice and on the 28th January 2018, the Court ruled that the doctor’s name be erased from the Medical Register, ostensibly to protect public confidence in the profession.



Final comments



The case of Dr Hadiza Hawa-Garba and the Court action taken by the GMC against Dr Hawa-Garba and the subsequent erasure of her name from the Medical Register has created controversy, and has raised several areas of concern for doctors working not only in UK, but all over the world. One being that Dr Hawa-Garba has been unduly punished for system failings, especially the understaffing. It has also generated fear among junior doctors. A reflective note written by Dr Hawa-Garba on e-portfolio was allegedly used in evidence against her.




More than 8,000 doctors have signed a petition in her support, a crowd funding campaign has raised over £260,000 for an appeal against the decision.



Dr Hawa-Garba was held responsible for a sequence of failings.



She did not recognize the early features of sepsis in the child and as such appropriate antibiotic treatment was delayed.



She appeared not to recognize the implications of seriously deranged blood gas results and failed to fully communicate the implications to her consultant.



When the child suffered a cardiac arrest there was a further problem as the patient was wrongly identified as another child for whom a DNACPR order applied.



Inquiry revealed that multiple errors and failings contributed to the mishap. No one cause could be found that led to the death of the patient.


Dr Hawa-Garba had only recently returned to work following maternity leave



She was covering the work of another registrar, with her supervising consultant teaching on a different site, and the two junior colleagues, for whom she had supervisory responsibility, had no pediatric experience.



She was expected to review unwell patients and perform procedures on six wards over four floors, field the GP calls and struggle without a functioning IT system.



The patient was shifted to a bed previously occupied by a patient with a DNR order; that change had been made without her knowledge. She was blamed for failing to recognize this.



Implications of this judgment for us


Such a case has now happened in the UK. We face this situation every day in India. And an event such as this is waiting to happen in our country.




Resident doctors can be called the backbone of the hospital. They work long shifts. At times, they may have to continue shift, which may extend to as long as 36 hours, to cover for their colleague without break, putting the needs of the patients first rather than their own. Such an overworked and exhausted doctor is liable to make mistakes.




In Martin F. D’Souza vs Mohd. Ishfaq SCI: 3541 of 2002, dated 17.02.2009, the Supreme Court of India had observed that “The higher the acuteness in an emergency and the higher the complication, the more are the chances of error of judgment...” Errors can be made in an emergency even by experts and may not amount to negligence.




The judgment in the case of Dr Hawa-Garba may impact decisions in cases of medical negligence in India too and error of judgment may no longer be a defense.




We have been fighting against criminal prosecution of doctors, but such judgments may weaken our stand on this issue.




What this judgment also implies that if you are overworked, ask for help. And, if there is staff shortage or you do not have adequate staff to share the volume of work, report it to your superior.




But even with the prevalent staff shortages, inadequate or poor infrastructure, can residents/doctors really refuse to work to save themselves from such a possible criminal conviction? And also from possible employer retribution?




Like a batsman in cricket, a single error can ruin your career.


With the rising trend of litigation and violence against the medical profession, clinical medicine may well become defensive medicine.


What can be done For Residents



Let your senior know about lack of adequate staffing, availability of support, IT functionality or other system issues.



If you write your experience in e-Portfolio, do not put the name of the patient or other such details.



Do not make any judgmental statement about any patient or staff involved in patient care. Avoid emotive language.



Consult with your seniors for such potentially serious cases.



For Consultants



Be proactive in ensuring a safe and supportive environment for your staff so that they can report incidents and clinical concerns. Encourage reflective practice for your residents without fear of legal action.



Discuss such issues with residents as their Educational Supervisor or Clinical Supervisor.

 Disclaimer: Welthi.com does not guarantee any specific results as a result of the procedures mentioned here, and the results may vary from person to person. Read more
Rare and complex Combined Liver and Kidney Transplant performed at Apollo Hospitals

Rare and complex Combined Liver and Kidney ...

Rare and complex Combined Liver and Kidney Transpl...
Aadya Skanda Diagnostic Center Inaugurated Arekapudi Gandhi, MLA was chief guest

Aadya Skanda Diagnostic Center Inaugurated ...

Aadya Skanda Diagnostic Center Inaugurated Arekapu...
Kohinoor Hospital Saves Life of a Woman Suffering from Head Injury in A Fatal Accident

Kohinoor Hospital Saves Life of a Woman ...

Kohinoor Hospital Saves Life of a Woman Suffering ...


World Parkinsons disease day April 11th

World Parkinsons disease day April 11th

World Parkinsons disease day April 11th...
A NOVEL INITIATIVE FOR A NOBLE CAUSE Olive Hospitals Presents Ramadan Relishes Nourishing Assortment of Nutritious Recipes


Wockhardt Hospital, Mira Road conducts free general health check-up for cops

Wockhardt Hospital, Mira Road conducts free ...

Wockhardt Hospital, Mira Road conducts free genera...
SuVitas Launches Bangalore’s First Dedicated Transition Care Facility

SuVitas Launches Bangalore’s First Dedicated ...

Catering to a need for post critical care that has...
Itermittent Fasting: The How s and Why's

Itermittent Fasting: The How s and Why's

Intermittent Fasting is the latest global fitness ...
Eyes show you the world

Eyes show you the world

With increasing rate of air pollution, the ways it...
Healthcare receives major limelight in General Budget 2018-19

Healthcare receives major limelight in General ...

Healthcare has been a core segment in every develo...